About Barrow / Directory / Insurance Agents
Anybody can quote you a policy, and 13 of the 27 ranked agencies here hold a perfect 5.0, so what these reviews are actually about is what happened when somebody filed a claim. Ranked by Google rating weighted for review volume, across Winder, Auburn, Statham, Bethlehem and Braselton.
What the numbers say about insurance agents in Barrow County ↓
These 4 have fewer than 5 Google reviews, which is not enough to rank one against another without guessing. They each have a page, and they move onto the list above as soon as the reviews are there.
31 insurance agencies operate in Barrow County. 27 of them have at least five Google reviews, and between them they hold 2,145.
This is a strong category, so read the ratings against a higher bar. The average across the 27 is 4.78, which is high enough that a 4.4 lands near the bottom of this page while it would sit mid-table in most trades. 19 of the 27 are at 4.8 or better and only 1 is below 4.0. Insurance customers who leave reviews mostly leave good ones. Read a 4.3 here as average rather than as a warning.
Nearly half of them hold a perfect score. 13 of the 27 sit at 5.0, which tells you the rating on its own cannot separate the top of this page. What separates them is how many people stood behind it, and the median agency here has only 39 reviews. The busiest has 349.
Winder has 19 of the ranked agencies. The spread is Winder 19, Braselton 4, Bethlehem 2, Auburn 2. Braselton spans four counties, so the ones here are the agencies whose addresses sit on the Barrow side of the line.
About a third carry a carrier's name on the door. A hand count in September found five State Farm agents, two American Family, and one each for Allstate, GEICO, Farmers and Georgia Farm Bureau, with the rest independent. That classification is a manual snapshot rather than a live figure. What matters for you is the difference it makes: a captive agent sells one company's policies, an independent shops several. Neither is better, they are different jobs, and the reviews do not distinguish between them.
4 of the 27 have no website. In this trade that is unusual, and it generally means a small independent office that runs on referrals.
Another 4 agencies are listed below the ranking with fewer than five reviews each. An insurance office can run for years on word of mouth without collecting reviews, so a thin count here says less about the business than it would in most categories.
What this page cannot tell you is the thing you actually want to know, which is how they behave on a claim. Most reviews here are written at the point of sale, by somebody happy with a quote, long before anything has gone wrong. Ask anyone you call how they handle a claim, who you reach at the weekend, and whether they do the filing or hand you a phone number.
Because 13 agencies here hold one, and they cannot all be first.
The ranking multiplies a rating by the confidence its review count has earned, so when the scores are tied the review counts break the tie. A 5.0 backed by a few dozen customers outranks a 5.0 backed by six, and a 4.9 backed by hundreds can outrank both.
Same formula on every page of this site, and it is published so you can run it yourself.
Every number on this page comes from Google. We do not score businesses ourselves, we do not take payment for placement, and we do not remove a business because it ranks badly. The only thing we add is the weighting for review volume.
By Google rating, weighted by how many reviews a business has. A perfect five stars from thirty customers does not outrank a 4.9 from four hundred and fifty. Nothing on this page is paid for and nobody can buy a higher position.
We track 31 operating insurance agents with public Google listings across Winder, Auburn, Statham, Bethlehem and Braselton. 27 of them have at least 5 reviews and are ranked above, holding 2,145 reviews between them.
Tell us and we will fix it the same week. Most of what is here comes straight from your Google Business Profile, so updating that usually updates this too. Start here.
The newsletter
What is happening this week, and what changed. Free, and I do not sell the list.
Subscribe