About Barrow / Directory / Tree Service
Storm damage does not wait for business hours. 11 of the 12 ranked tree services here are rated 4.8 or better, so ask about insurance before you ask about stars. Ranked by Google rating weighted for review volume, across Winder, Auburn, Statham, Bethlehem and Braselton.
These 3 have fewer than 5 Google reviews, which is not enough to rank one against another without guessing. They each have a page, and they move onto the list above as soon as the reviews are there.
15 tree services are listed here. 12 carry the five reviews needed to be ranked, and between them they hold 479. 3 do not have five reviews yet.
This category ties plumbing for the highest average rating on the site, at 4.85. 11 of the 12 are at 4.8 or better and 7 hold a perfect 5.0. The difference is that plumbing earns its 4.85 across more than five thousand reviews and this page earns it across 479. Same number, nothing like the same confidence behind it.
The most reviewed company on this page finishes eleventh, and that is the clearest example on the whole site of what the weighting actually does. It rates 4.8 across 132 reviews, which is the best evidenced number here by a distance. But the average in this category is 4.85, so a well proven 4.8 is a well proven slightly below average. The ranking does not reward volume for its own sake. It rewards being above the pack with enough people behind you to believe it, and in a category this uniformly high the pack is very hard to clear.
The median company here has 27 reviews. That is small. Four of the perfect 5.0s on this page rest on 22, 16, 10 and 8 reviews. They are ranked where they are because eight happy customers is good news rather than proof, and the formula says so by pulling those scores back toward 4.85 until more people turn up.
5 of the 12 have no website at all. That is the second highest share of any category on this site, behind auto repair. Tree work in this county runs on a phone number, a truck and word of mouth, and several of the companies with no website are near the top. Do not read a missing website as a warning here.
The ranked companies break down as Winder 6, Auburn 3, Statham 1, Bethlehem 1, Braselton 1. Every town in the county is represented, which is unusual on this site. Crews travel for this kind of work, so distance matters less than whether they can get the equipment down your driveway. Say up front if the tree is near the house, near the power line, or behind a fence, because all three change the quote and two of them change who is willing to take the job.
This is the trade where the paperwork matters most. A mistake here puts a tree through a roof or a person in hospital, and if the company is uninsured that becomes your problem and your homeowner's claim. Ask for a certificate of insurance sent directly from their insurer, not a photo of one, and check that it covers both general liability and workers compensation. Ask who is responsible if something falls the wrong way. Get the cleanup and the stump written into the quote rather than assumed, because that is where most of the arguments start. No rating on this page tells you any of that.
Because of what the rest of this category looks like.
The weighting pulls every rating toward the category average in proportion to how little evidence it has. In most categories that average sits below the leaders, so the pull drags small scores down and the big ones hold their place. Here the average is 4.85, which is higher than almost anywhere else on the site. A 5.0 with 8 reviews gets pulled down toward 4.85, and it does not have far to fall. A 4.8 with 132 reviews barely moves at all, and it was already sitting below 4.85 before the arithmetic started.
So the honest reading is not that the 4.8 is a bad company. It is that in a county where nearly every tree service is rated 4.8 or better, a 4.8 is the floor rather than the ceiling. That is a real finding about this category, and it is the kind of thing a plain star rating hides from you.
Same formula on every page of this site, and it is published so you can run it yourself.
Every number on this page comes from Google. We do not score businesses ourselves, we do not take payment for placement, and we do not remove a business because it ranks badly. The only thing we add is the weighting for review volume.
By Google rating, weighted by how many reviews a business has. A perfect five stars from thirty customers does not outrank a 4.9 from four hundred and fifty. Nothing on this page is paid for and nobody can buy a higher position.
We track 15 operating tree services with public Google listings across Winder, Auburn, Statham, Bethlehem and Braselton. 12 of them have at least 5 reviews and are ranked above, holding 479 reviews between them.
Tell us and we will fix it the same week. Most of what is here comes straight from your Google Business Profile, so updating that usually updates this too. Start here.
The newsletter
What is happening this week, and what changed. Free, and I do not sell the list.
Subscribe