About Barrow / Directory / Roofing
Most roofing calls start with hail or a leak, and 8 of the 16 ranked companies hold a perfect 5.0, so the star rating will not pick one for you. Ranked by Google rating weighted for review volume, across Winder, Auburn, Statham, Bethlehem and Braselton.
What the numbers say about roofing companies in Barrow County ↓
These 11 have fewer than 5 Google reviews, which is not enough to rank one against another without guessing. They each have a page, and they move onto the list above as soon as the reviews are there.
27 roofing companies serve the county. Only 16 of them carry the five reviews needed to be ranked, which is the thinnest evidence of any category on this site. Between them those 16 hold 944 reviews. The restaurants page holds 37,779.
The star rating is close to useless here, and that is worth knowing before you start calling. The average ranked roofer in Barrow County sits at 4.83, the highest average of any category on this site. 8 of the 16 hold a perfect 5.0. 0 are below 4.0. Auto repair averages 4.62 and restaurants 4.40. If almost everybody is excellent, the rating is not telling you who to call.
The review counts are small, and that is the structural reason. The median company here has 34 reviews. A roof is something most people buy once or twice in a lifetime, so even a company that stays busy for years accumulates reviews at a fraction of the rate a restaurant does. Five happy customers is five happy customers. It is not a track record.
One company has 311 reviews and is nowhere near the top. That looks like a mistake and it is not. It is explained at the bottom of this page, and it is the clearest example on the whole site of what the weighting is actually doing.
Winder has 9 of them. Across the county the spread is Winder 9, Bethlehem 2, Hoschton 1, Braselton 1, Auburn 1, Monroe 1, Statham 1, and a couple do not list a town at all. Roofers travel, so proximity matters less here than in most categories. It matters for one thing only, which is how fast somebody can get a tarp on your house while the rain is still coming.
Only 0 of the 16 have no website. That makes this the most marketed category in the directory. In auto repair it is 22 of 50. Read it as a sign of how competitive roofing sales are around here rather than as a sign of quality. It costs more to find a roofing customer than an oil change customer, so the companies that spend on finding you are the ones you will hear from first.
Another 11 companies are listed below the ranking with fewer than five reviews each. In a trade this expensive, a company with no track record yet is worth a second look at who is behind it rather than an automatic no.
What none of these numbers can tell you is who is actually going to be on your roof. Plenty of roofing is subcontracted, and the crew that shows up may not work for the name on the truck. Before you sign, ask three things, in writing: who performs the work, what the warranty covers and who honours it, and whether they carry current liability and workers compensation cover. Ask for the certificate rather than the assurance. Then get a second quote, because a roof is the most expensive thing on this site by a wide margin.
Because its rating is below average for a roofer in this county, and having 311 reviews makes that more certain rather than less.
The ranking pulls every rating toward the category average in proportion to how little evidence backs it. In most categories that average sits in the low to mid fours, so a 4.7 looks strong. Here the average is 4.83. A 4.7 is under it.
So the company with hundreds of reviews keeps almost exactly its own score, because hundreds of people is a real sample and there is nothing to correct. The 5.0 companies with five or seven reviews get pulled most of the way back toward 4.83, because five people is not yet evidence. Both end up in the same neighbourhood, and the one whose own customers rated it below the county average finishes lower.
That is not a judgement about the work. It is arithmetic, it is the same arithmetic on every page of this site, and it is published so you can run it yourself.
Every number on this page comes from Google. We do not score businesses ourselves, we do not take payment for placement, and we do not remove a business because it ranks badly. The only thing we add is the weighting for review volume.
By Google rating, weighted by how many reviews a business has. A perfect five stars from thirty customers does not outrank a 4.9 from four hundred and fifty. Nothing on this page is paid for and nobody can buy a higher position.
We track 27 operating roofing companies with public Google listings across Winder, Auburn, Statham, Bethlehem and Braselton. 16 of them have at least 5 reviews and are ranked above, holding 944 reviews between them.
Tell us and we will fix it the same week. Most of what is here comes straight from your Google Business Profile, so updating that usually updates this too. Start here.
The newsletter
What is happening this week, and what changed. Free, and I do not sell the list.
Subscribe